Are Leading Indicator Surveys Accurate?

Create-Surveys-e1610135407292

Surveys regarding injury and illness leading indicators are used frequently in the construction industry for contract bidding purposes, but are they really accurate? A new research report says they are. Because the effectiveness of such surveys had never been proven, the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH)-funded Center for Construction Research and Training supported the research. Researchers found higher survey scores of leading indicators were linked to worksites with a greater safety climate and lower injury rates, according to a story in NIOSH’s December 2020 newsletter.

Construction sites and projects appeared more critical in increasing safety than specific subcontracting companies. Results suggest the importance of safety for the overall construction project and its worksite as both relate to workers “perhaps somewhat independent of the individual subcontractor level.”

The research was conducted by researchers at Northeastern University in Boston as part of a larger project called Assessment of Contractor Safety (ACES).

Researchers designed and tested a 63-item organizational survey assessing subcontractors’ leading indicators of safety performance, which was filled out by 43 subcontractors on 24 construction sites.

At the same time, they conducted a survey of 1,426 workers on those same sites and recorded injury rates for the duration of each project.

Worksites, Not Companies

At the worksite level, higher average ACES scores were associated with higher worker safety climate scores and lower rates of injury involving days away.

However, within subcontracting companies, no associations were observed between ACES scores and worker safety climate scores and injuries.

The study appeared in the American Journal of Industrial Medicine.

Purchase NASP’s Certified Safety Manager Course

Related Posts

What we learned from 300 safety professionals on psychological health and safety

What we learned from 300 safety professionals on psychological health and safety

07.16.2025 Psychological Health and Safety
Last week, nearly 300 safety professionals from across North America joined a NASP webinar on psychological health and safety (PHS).…
Read More
A Shifting Landscape: Analyzing OSHA’s Proposed Changes to Respirator Medical Evaluations

A Shifting Landscape: Analyzing OSHA’s Proposed Changes to Respirator Medical Evaluations

07.11.2025 Compliance
A significant change may be on the horizon for how we manage respiratory protection programs. The Occupational Safety and Health…
Read More
Strengthening Communication and Trust to Protect Bilingual Construction Workers

Strengthening Communication and Trust to Protect Bilingual Construction Workers

07.11.2025 Safety Culture
Language and cultural barriers continue to pose serious challenges to workplace safety in the U.S. construction industry, where Hispanic workers…
Read More
cta1-img

See our available Live and online cOURSES